Advertisement

Breaking news: Appeals court upholds USDA decision to commercialize biotech alfalfa

The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has refused to overturn the USDA's decision to comme ...

Posted: Thursday, February 21, 2013 12:00 PM



Content ImageContent Image

Eldon



Advertisement




Politics ignore middle

By JON ELDON

For the Capital Press

Culture wars are all around us. Or at least they seem to be, when we ignore the numerous reasonable discussions and instead focus on the vocal minorities at the extremes.

Take the now-popular "red state-blue state" concept. Pink, purple or -- heaven forbid! -- red-blue states are now only mentioned in the days leading up to an election and even then only until they "go" one way or the other. Never mind the fact that these colors are often separated by a few percentage points at most.

For decades, we as a society have used a similar approach to describe the supposed division between agriculture and environmental interests. This contrast is often presented with all the nuance of the old bumper sticker from Northwest timber country: "Are you an environmentalist, or do you work for a living?"

In reality, this is not a divide between competing alternatives, but rather an overlap of interests. So to answer that question -- well it's just not a good question in the first place. See, if you cut all the trees down then you won't be working for a living for very long, but if you don't cut down any then you might find yourself working real hard to stay alive.

Instead, why don't we focus on more practical questions, such as how many to cut, when, where, how and to what purpose?

The vast majority of farmers and ranchers are aware of environmental concerns, just as the vast majority of environmentalists are aware that agriculture is an essential part of any environmental discussion.

How environmental concerns can be met without undermining agriculture -- well, now, that's a serious question -- and denying one interest or the other doesn't get us anywhere closer to addressing it.

This practical approach is increasingly reflected by the activities of people who should, by all accounts, be at war, such as The Nature Conservancy and the California Cattleman's Association.

This is not to say that strong disagreement within the overlap between agricultural and environmental interests will not continue, but it is probably about time that we stop discussing these issues as if they are a struggle of good versus evil (or evil versus good, depending on which side you're on).

As a society we are certainly not ready to all hold hands and sing "Kumbaya" around a campfire. That is not a realistic or even a very appealing goal, but we could certainly do a better job of ignoring the heckling from the cheap seats.

With an increasing number of farmers and ranchers turning to social media and other outlets to tell their stories, and an increasing number of college graduates leaving the cities to apply themselves to the business end of a shovel, we can hardly even claim that there is a communication problem anymore -- unless it is one of our own making.

If we are to address any of the important problems facing agriculture and the environment, we need to at least begin our arguments by recognizing our shared interests and common ground. Let the 1 percent on both "sides" scream themselves hoarse. The rest of us in the middle have work to do.

Jon Eldon is an agricultural scientist completing his doctorate at the University of California-Santa Cruz.

He has previously worked as a commercial fisherman, wildland firefighter and farm laborer.

Comments made about this article

Comment on this article

You must LOGIN to post comments

Advertisement

Copyright © 2009-2013 Capital Press, MediaSpan and The Associated Press where indicated. All rights reserved.

Contact Capital Press at 1-800-882-6789 or click here to find our staff listing.

Site optimized for use with Firefox browser, Ver. 16.0.1

Privacy Policies: Capital Press | MediaSpan Online Services

Other Capital Press websites:

Capital Press | OnlyAg.com | Ag Ads Now | Farm Seller | Ag Directory West | Blogriculture agriculture blog and podcasts

Our sister EO Media Group websites:

The Daily Astorian | Coast Weekend | AstoriaRocks.com | Chinook Observer
Oregon Coast Today | Seaside-Sun.com| Seaside Signal| Cannon Beach Gazette
Coast River Business Journal
Hermiston Herald | East Oregonian | Eastern Oregon Real Estate | EO Marketplace
Blue Mountain Eagle | Wallowa County Chieftain