ONLINE Dan Fulleton Farm Equipment Retirement Auction
THIS WILL BE AN ONLINE AUCTION Visit bakerauction.com for full sale list and information Auction Soft Close: Mon., March 3rd, 2025 @ 12:00pm MT Location: 3550 Fulleton Rd. Vale, OR […]
Published 4:07 am Wednesday, September 12, 2018
The vaguely threatening letter over alleged patent infringement that Azure Farms received last year didn’t make much of an impression on David Stelzer.
Stelzer, the company’s founder and CEO, consulted with his information technology employees, who assumed the letter was a scam.
“I didn’t give it a second thought,” he said.
Now, the Oregon company is the defendant in a lawsuit that alleges its online website for selling organic food and other products has violated a patent for automated financial transactions owned by Landmark Technology LLC of San Diego, Calif.
Stelzer said his website isn’t much different from multitudes of others that sell products online, making him think the plaintiff has filed a “nuisance lawsuit” aimed at a quick settlement.
Azure Farms, based in Dufur, Ore., doesn’t have deep pockets to hire expensive attorneys, which is perhaps why the company was targeted, he said.
“I have no clue what they are after,” said Stelzer, who farms nearly 2,000 acres. “They’re basically saying because we have a working website, we have patent violations.”
According to the complaint, Azure Farms’ website contains numerous functions protected by a patent issued in 2001 that the company should be enjoined from further violating. Landmark Technology also seeks damages for past infringement in an amount to be proven at trial.
“It would be difficult to ascertain the amount of compensation that would afford Landmark adequate relief for such future and continuing acts, and a multiplicity of judicial proceedings would be required,” the complaint said.
John Mansfield, attorney for Landmark Technology, referred questions to his boss, Bill Charters, who wasn’t available for comment as of press time.
Azure Farms isn’t alone in its quandary.
Landmark Technology has been involved in about 170 federal lawsuits — mostly as a plaintiff, but occasionally as a defendant against companies seeking a “declaratory judgment” that they haven’t committed patent infringement, according to court records.
In one such case, the Fabletics online clothing company called Landmark Technology a “patent troll” whose “business model is sending letters threatening patent litigation and following through on that threat.” The lawsuit has since settled for undisclosed terms.
Most such litigation settles fairly quickly due to cost pressures, rather than the merit of the allegations, said Daniel Nazer, senior staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a nonprofit that defends “civil liberties in the digital world.”
Even the simplest patent lawsuit is rarely litigated through trial for less than $1 million, while bigger cases commonly cost more than $10 million, Nazer said.
“Patent litigation is sometimes called the sport of kings,” he said. “They tend to be complicated cases with experts and a lot of document discovery.”
While it’s technically possible for companies that successfully defend themselves against such lawsuits to recover attorney fees, that outcome is rare enough that many defendants don’t take the chance, Nazer said.
The problem would be mitigated if the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office declined to approve patents for overly broad claims, he said. “Generally, we think the patent office needs to do a better job of policing obviousness and not giving patents to mundane business processes on a computer.”
“Non-practicing entities” — the official name for companies that do nothing but sue over patents — have been dealt a couple legal setbacks in recent years, said David Donoghue, a patent trial attorney with the Holland & Knight law firm.
In 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that enshrining a conventional business transaction in computer code wasn’t enough to make the method eligible for a patent in a case known as Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank.
In 2011, the America Invents Act was signed into law, allowing defendants in such cases to ask the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to reconsider the validity of a disputed patent, said Donoghue.
This administrative process of “inter partes review,” or IPR, is less expensive than traditional lawsuits, which are often stayed while the agency deliberates, he said.
These two changes haven’t entirely prevented complaints seeking to extract license fees because defendants still often prefer to settle, Donoghue said.
Even so, the value of dubious patents has been reduced, so the financial “sweet spot” of settling such cases has also fallen, he said.
The phenomenon remains troubling for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, since such lawsuits effectively penalize companies like Azure Farms from stepping up their online marketing, Nazer said.
“It disincentivizes people from being entrepreneurial,” he said.
THIS WILL BE AN ONLINE AUCTION Visit bakerauction.com for full sale list and information Auction Soft Close: Mon., March 3rd, 2025 @ 12:00pm MT Location: 3550 Fulleton Rd. Vale, OR […]
Featuring quality surplus farm and dairy equipment from farming operations and dealers across Western, WA. Highlights include sellers from Lynden to Snohomish featuring equipment from Farmers Equipment, Inc., Cleave Farms, […]
Bid Now! Bidding Ends March 12, 10 AM MST Dairy, farm, excavation & heavy equipment, transportation, tools, & more! Register Now! Magic Valley Auction www.MVAidaho.com 208-536-5000
Treasure Valley Livestock Auction Caldwell, Idaho Free Delivery within 400 Miles February 25th, 2025 @ 1PM MST VIEW/BID LIVE ON THE INTERNET: LiveAuctions.TV Find us on Facebook at: Idaho […]
The in-person and virtual conference will feature more than 90 speakers, as well as presentations, panel discussions and networking. Organic Seed Alliance (OSA), along with partner Oregon State University’s Center […]
Live Streaming Auction - February 26, 2025 Timed Auction (Online Only!) - February 27, 2025 View Catalogs: Day 1 | Day 2
Range-Raised • Feedlot-Tested • Carcass-Measured • DNA Evaluated Price Cattle Company with Murdock Cattle Co February 26 Lunch Served At 11:00 AM • Sale Starts 1:00 PM 50 Registered Angus […]
The event features research updates and educational presentations.
Live Streaming Auction - February 26, 2025 Timed Auction (Online Only!) - February 27, 2025 View Catalogs: Day 1 | Day 2
Moving Back Home! In addition to our yearling bulls, we also added some age-advantage bulls. The sale will take place at the Lewiston Roundup Grounds, just South of Lewiston. Both […]
FRIDAY – February 28, 2025 / 8:30 AM 17129 HIGHWAY 99 NE, WOODBURN, OR 97071 AUCTION DETAILS: Auction Begins: Friday – February 28th, 2025 @ 8:30 AM – (PST) Live-online […]
Trinity Farms BETTER BULLS. BRIGHTER FUTURES. Trinity composite bulls, the perfect solution for advanced beef production. 250 Bulls Available Ellensburg, WA • 3.1.2025 www.trinityfarms.info • (509) 201-0775
Preview: Sat. March 1st 9am - 1 pm Biddings Ends: Thurs. March 6th Starting at 6pm Highlights Include: Bulb planter and harvest equipment, disks, plows, harrows, cultipackers, 4 row planter, […]
Heavy Equipment • Tractors • Construction • Farm Equipment • Vehicles • Trucks • Trailers & More! Virtual Online-Only Auction Full Catalog & Bidding Procedures Available at www.yarbro.com Start […]
Booker's Annual Early Spring Eltopia Auction March 6-7, 2025 www.BookerAuction.com | 509.297.9292
2-Day Online Equipment Auction @ Meridian Equipment Auction CO, Bellingham WA. Now Accepting Quality Machinery Consignments AUCTION INFORMATION Online Only Bidding ONLINE BIDDING OPENS: Feb 22, 2025 DAY 1- Online […]
Oregon State University Surplus hosts Annual Farm Sale Bid on 30+ years of local farm surplus! Join OSU Surplus on March 8th at the Lewis Brown Farm in Corvallis for the […]
Join us for the Genetic Edge Bull Sale! 320 Coming Two-Year-Old Bulls • 265 Yearling Bulls • 305 Calving-Ease Bulls Schedule of Events Friday, March 7, 2025 All Day […]
March Online Equipment Consignment Auction Online Bidding is Wed, March 12th - Wed, March 19th Chehalis Livestock Market 328 Hamilton Rd. N., Chehalis, WA 98532 Follow Us on Facebook! @Chehalis […]
Online Auction - March 12th Bid Now! Dairy, Farm, Excavation & Heavy Equipment, Transportation, Tools, & More! Magic Valley Auction MVAidaho.com 208-536-5000
Bidding starts on Wednesday, March 12th Go to www.clmauctions.com and click on Hibid link to view and bid on over 1,000 lots! Lots of great pickups, trailers, tractors, cars, farm trucks, haying […]
ONLINE ONLY AUCTION Schritter Farms Retirement Auction Bidding Now Open! Bids Begin Closing on March 12th @ 9AM MST Multiple Locations - Please See Individual Lots For Their Specific Location, […]
Thursday, March 13th at 9:30 AM ~ Bill Miller Rentals ~ Rubbered Tired Loaders, Crawler Tractors, Cranes, Motor Graders, Haul Trucks, Excavators, Water Trucks, Truck Tractors, Trailers, Attachments and Support […]
RAM RIDGE LLC & PALM CONSTRUCTION - ONLINE AUCTION Aggregate Crushing & Heavy Equipment Start Date: 10AM | Thursday - March 13 End Date: 10AM | Thursday - March 20 […]
Thursday, March 13th at 9:30 AM Rubber Tired Loaders, Crawler Tractors, Cranes, Motor Graders, Haul Trucks, Excavators, Water Trucks, Truck Tractors, Trailers, Attachments and Support Equipment Carlin (Elko), Nevada HIGHLIGHTS: […]
March 14th - March 18th 2025 Changes Farm Operations Maxwell, CA Learn more at AUCTION-IS-ACTION.COM Putnam Auctioneers, Inc. CA Bond No. 7238559 Email: putman.kevin@yahoo.com John Putnam - (530) 710-8596 Kevin […]
Saturday, March 15th 9:30 AM Address: 1800 West Bonanza Rd., Las Vegas, NV 89106 Highlights: 2-Tele. Forklifts: Unused JLG 943, Unused JLG 742, 2-Cab & Chassis: (2)Unused Chevy 5500, 3-Detachable […]
March Online Auction Begins to close @3pm MST | March 17, 2025 Early Listings: *2017 Bobcat 418-A-A Mini Excavator, *International 544 Utility Tractor with Loader, *2016 Bobcat E20 Mini Excavator, […]
Multi-Seller - Open Consignment Bidding Now Open - Additional Items Arriving Daily Starts Closing: Tuesday, March 18th @ 2PM (MT) Tractors • Trucks • Trailers • Construction Equipment • Farm […]
Machinery Auction March 19 & 20 All lots start to close at 8:00 a.m. PST Online Bidding Opens March 14 at 3:00 p.m. PST Items include: Construction Equipment, […]
12:30PM Wednesday, March 19, 2025 Performance Tested Bulls: Angus, Simmental and SimAngus, Red Angus, Charolais 90 Day Breeding Guarantee. Western Breeders Assoc. Bonina Feed and Sale Facility, 430 Ferguson Lane, […]
Booker's Annual Early Spring Offsite Farm Auction Ends March 19, 2025 www.BookerAuction.com | 509.297.9292
MAJOR CONSIGNORS: Twin Falls Highway District; KWS Seeds; Molyneux Family Farms; and Sev'rl Area Farmers throughout the Magic Valley NOTICE: Items listing in this auction are located at multiple locations […]
Saturday, March 22, 2025 1:00pm PT • At the Ranch • Sandpoint, ID High maternal easy fleshing Cows Low maintenance Heifers High performance Bulls Selling 47 Bulls and 40 […]
Discover the Estate of Afton Jacobson, offering 743± acres of farmland just 4 miles south of Pullman, WA. This expansive property features 6 parcels, two including residences and outbuildings, providing […]
FRIDAY – April 25, 2025 / 8:30 AM 17129 HIGHWAY 99 NE, WOODBURN, OR 97071 *Catalog coming soon* AUCTION DETAILS: Auction Begins: Friday – April 25th, 2025 @ 8:30 AM […]
Live Streaming Auction - March 26, 2025 Timed Auction (Online Only!) - March 27th, 2025 View Catalogs: Day 1 | Day 2
March 28th, 9:00 am - 5:00 pm March 29th, 9:00 am - 3 pm The 4th Annual Central Oregon Agricultural Show presents the best of the region’s agricultural industry. The […]
FRIDAY – March 28, 2025 / 8:30 AM 17129 HIGHWAY 99 NE, WOODBURN, OR 97071 AUCTION DETAILS: Auction Begins: Friday – March 28th, 2025 @ 8:30 AM – (PST) Live-online […]
ONLINE ONLY AUCTION Rowell Bros. Berry Farm Liquidation Preview: Sunday, March 30th 9AM to 2PM 24000 SW SCHOLLS FERRY RD. HILLSBORO, OR. Online Bidding Ends Thursday evening, April 3 starting […]
Bids Open at 3pm PST on March 20th Start Closing at 8am PST, April 2 & 3, 2025 On-Site Preview available Monday to Saturday from 9am to 4pm Visit www.I-5auctions.com […]
Thursday, April 3, 2025 - Brigham City, Utah Live & Online Bidding (16) Tractors - Wheel loaders - Skid Steers - (8) Semis, Trucks w/Laird Feed Box, Ross Beds - […]
THIS WILL BE AN ONLINE AUCTION Go to bakerauction.com for more information. Auction Soft Closes: Thurs., April 3rd 2025 @ 12:00pm MT Consignment Item Receiving: March 17th - March 31st, […]